
| Seconds | Check | Good sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0–10 | Box | Plywood, with clean, covered front edges | Crumbly particle board edges, thin flexing sides |
| 10–20 | Drawer corners | Dovetail joints | Staples or nails at the corners |
| 20–30 | Slides | Full extension, soft-close | Short rollers that stop partway out |
| 30–40 | Hinges | Concealed, soft-close, adjustable | Wobble when the open door is lifted |
| 40–50 | Back | Set into the sides, with a solid place to fix to the wall | A thin back stapled on the outside |
| 50–60 | Finish | Even inside and out, edges coated | Rough edges, raw interiors, drips |
1. The box (0–10 seconds)
Open a door and look at the inside of the side panel and its front edge.
- Plywood shows thin layers at a cut edge. Particle board shows pressed chips.
- Push on the side from inside. It should not flex.
- Exposed front edges should be covered by edge banding or a face frame.
Thickness depends on construction. A frameless box relies on its sides alone, so they should be substantial. A framed box gets stiffness from the solid face frame on the front. Ours are plywood: 3/4-inch on frameless, and 1/2-inch behind a solid face frame on framed, with 3/4-inch available. Look hardest at the sink base: that is where water gets in and weak material fails first. See frameless and face frame compared.
2. Drawer joinery (10–20 seconds)
Pull a drawer all the way out and look at the corners of the box, not the decorative front.
- Dovetails, interlocking pins and tails, are the strongest common joint.
- Staples or nails through a butt joint loosen over time.
- The bottom should sit in a groove on all four sides, not be stapled underneath.
3. Slides (20–30 seconds)
- Full extension means the drawer comes all the way out, so you can reach the back.
- Soft close pulls it shut gently.
- Press down on the front of the open drawer. A good slide stays smooth and barely sags.
Cheap roller slides with plastic wheels are a giveaway on a budget line.

4. Hinges (30–40 seconds)
Concealed soft-close hinges from established hardware makers are normal on quality cabinets. Check that:
- The hinge adjusts three ways, side, height and depth, so the door can be set straight.
- The door closes softly without slamming.
- There is no play when you lift the open door slightly.
5. The back (40–50 seconds)
- A back set into a groove or rabbet in the sides keeps the box square and stiff.
- A thicker back, or solid hanging rails, gives a secure place to screw into the wall studs.
- A thin back stapled onto the outside of the box is a sign of cost cutting.
Ask the seller how thick the back is and how the cabinet hangs.
6. The finish (50–60 seconds)
- Run a finger along a door edge. It should be smooth and fully coated.
- Colour and sheen should be even across doors and panels.
- No drips, runs or dust bumps on flat surfaces.
- Interiors should be finished, not raw wood.
A finish sprayed in a shop with the doors off reaches every edge. Ours are sprayed in our Concord shop; see kitchen cabinet finishes.
What else gives a cabinet away?
- Door gaps. Look along a run of doors. Gaps should be even and straight.
- Shelves. Thin shelves bow under dishes, especially in wide cabinets.
- Shelf pins. Metal pins in clean holes beat plastic clips.
- Toe kick. A solid, sealed toe kick stands up to mopping.
What should I ask the seller?
- What is the box made of, and how thick are the sides and back?
- How are the drawer boxes joined, and what slides are they on?
- What hinges do you use?
- How is the finish applied, and what is it?
- Do the cabinets arrive assembled?
A shop that builds well answers quickly and specifically. Ours arrive fully assembled, with full-extension dovetail drawers and soft-close hinges as standard.
Frequently asked questions
Does solid wood mean better cabinets?
Not always. Solid wood suits face frames and door frames, but plywood is more stable for boxes and panels.
Are soft-close hinges a sign of quality?
They are expected now. How well they adjust and how they are mounted matter more than the soft-close feature itself.
What is the most important thing to check?
The sink base box and the drawer construction. Those take the most abuse.
Can a cabinet look great and still be badly built?
Yes. Doors and paint can hide a weak box. Always open it up.
Related reading
- Plywood vs particle board vs MDF: which cabinet box material lasts
- Framed vs frameless cabinets: the pros and cons of each
We build every kitchen in our Concord shop and ship it fully assembled, including to Fargo, ND, South Lake Tahoe, CA, Sacramento, CA and Bakersfield, CA. See every city we deliver to.

Leave a Reply